RSA 421-B:6-613 · Hearing Procedures

421-B:6-613 Hearing Procedures. –

Copy link

(a)

Notwithstanding any other law to the contrary, all adjudicatory proceedings pursuant to this chapter shall be conducted by the secretary of state or by a presiding officer appointed by the secretary of state. All hearings conducted pursuant to this chapter shall be governed by the provisions of this section and the provisions of RSA 541-A shall not apply to this chapter.

Copy link

(b)

A document shall be considered filed when it is actually received at the department's office in Concord, New Hampshire, and conforms to the requirements of this chapter.

Copy link

(c)

For the purposes of this section:

Copy link

(1)

All complaints, petitions, motions, responses, and replies shall be signed by the proponent of the document or, if the party appears by a representative, by the representative.

Copy link

(2)

License, registration, and exemption applications shall be signed only by the applicant or properly authorized designee.

Copy link

(3)

The signature on a document filed with the department shall constitute a certification that:

Copy link

(A)

The signer has read the document and is authorized to file it;

Copy link

(B)

There are good grounds to support the representations made therein; and

Copy link

(C)

The document has not been filed for purposes of delay or harassment.

Copy link

(4)

A willful violation of subsection (c), shall, to the extent consistent with the policy of the statutes administered by the secretary of state, be a basis for entering an order adverse to the party committing the violation.

Copy link

(d)

Within a reasonable time after receipt of a complaint:

Copy link

(1)

The department staff or a presiding officer shall review the complaint to determine whether any basis exists for administrative action.

Copy link

(2)

If the complaint is insufficient or no basis exists which warrants administrative action, the complaint shall be dismissed and no hearing shall be scheduled on such complaint.

Copy link

(3)

If the staff determines that sufficient basis exists which warrants administrative action, the staff shall petition the secretary of state for relief.

Copy link

(4)

On any complaint, the staff shall temporarily defer any action and refer the subject matter of the complaint to the appropriate agency if a more complete investigation is necessary. The results of the investigation shall be used to determine the necessity of conducting a hearing by the department.

Copy link

(e)

Within a reasonable time after receipt of a petition:

Copy link

(1)

The secretary of state may issue an order either denying or granting the petition or granting in part and denying in part. If any part of the petition is granted, the respondent shall be informed, as part of the hearing notice, of the respondent's right to a hearing.

Copy link

(2)

A petition may include a request for summary action prior to a hearing.

Copy link

(3)

The staff may, sua sponte, petition for relief whenever it has reasonable grounds to believe that a violation of law has occurred, is occurring, or is about to occur.

Copy link

(f)

Notices of hearings shall:

Copy link

(1)

Be prepared and forwarded in a manner which affords interested persons sufficient opportunity to prepare for and deal with the issues to be considered and decided upon at the hearing.

Copy link

(2)

Given in writing and addressed to the address of record of the person being called in for the hearing. The notice shall be prepared on an official form of the department and shall be sent in a sealed envelope through the United States mail, personal services, or by Federal Express or other similar delivery service.

Copy link

(g)

A notice of hearing shall include:

Copy link

(1)

The time, date, and location of the hearing.

Copy link

(2)

The statute which has allegedly been violated and a statement of the legal authority under which the hearing is to be held.

Copy link

(3)

An explicit description of the alleged violation or a copy of the complaint or petition for relief or both the copy of complaint and petition for relief.

Copy link

(h)

Each hearing shall be set for a date as soon as practicable after the complaint has been received and reviewed. The hearing shall be scheduled to allow sufficient and reasonable time for the preparation of the case by both the department and interested parties.

Copy link

(i)

A request for continuance of a hearing shall be made in writing and received by the department, absent exigent circumstances, at least 5 working days prior to the hearing. Exigent circumstances include:

Copy link

(1)

Absence from the jurisdiction;

Copy link

(2)

Serious illness;

Copy link

(3)

Hospitalization;

Copy link

(4)

Death of a family member.

Copy link

(j)

The written request or motion for continuance shall contain the following:

Copy link

(1)

The specific reason or reasons for the request; and

Copy link

(2)

Optional dates and times when all interested parties shall be available.

Copy link

(k)

Each presiding officer may, at any stage of the hearing process, withdraw from a case if the presiding officer has or has had a personal or business relationship with any party, witness, or representative that may hinder such presiding officer from being able to arrive at an impartial decision on the issue or issues, or for any other reason that may interfere with the presiding officer's ability to remain impartial.

Copy link

(l)

Parties shall have the right to:

Copy link

(1)

Appear pro se or be represented by an attorney.

Copy link

(2)

Cross-examine witnesses; and

Copy link

(3)

Present evidence and witnesses on their own behalf.

Copy link

(m)

Except as provided as follows, administrative hearings shall be open to the public:

Copy link

(1)

The presiding officer may, on the presiding officer's own motion or at the request of a party, rule that the public be excluded from a hearing if necessary, pursuant to RSA 91-A:3, II, to protect the interests and rights of the parties to the hearing.

Copy link

(2)

In matters involving sensitive issues, a presiding officer may consult with the office of the attorney general for a ruling on the privacy issue.

Copy link

(3)

Members of the press shall be admitted to the hearing whenever the public is permitted. If the press is present at a hearing, the presiding officer shall brief them, off the record, in the presence of all parties, as to the nature and purpose of the hearing.

Copy link

(4)

In the event a party objects to the attendance of persons not involved in the hearing, the presiding officer shall ascertain the reason for such objection and determine whether the reason given justifies closing the hearing to such persons.

Copy link

(n)

Subject to the laws governing the department of state, and within the general scope of his powers, each presiding officer shall have the authority to:

Copy link

(1)

Schedule and hold hearings.

Copy link

(2)

Administer oaths and affirmations.

Copy link

(3)

Issue subpoenas on behalf of the state.

Copy link

(4)

Determine the order of proof in any proceeding.

Copy link

(5)

Receive relevant evidence and rule on offers of proof in hearings.

Copy link

(6)

Take judicial notice of any facts which are of common knowledge and general notoriety.

Copy link

(7)

Take, or cause to be taken, depositions.

Copy link

(8)

Regulate and control the course of an administrative hearing.

Copy link

(9)

Hold conferences for the settlement or simplification of issues, or for obtaining stipulations as to issues of fact or proof by consent of the parties.

Copy link

(10)

Dispose of procedural requests, including adjournments or continuances at the request of the parties or on the presiding officer's own motion.

Copy link

(11)

Interview and examine witnesses and parties as the case may require.

Copy link

(12)

Direct parties to appear at hearings.

Copy link

(13)

Consider and evaluate the facts and evidence on the record in making findings of fact and conclusions of law and dispositions.

Copy link

(14)

Determine credibility or weight of evidence in making findings of fact and conclusions of law.

Copy link

(15)

Render oral and written decisions, reports, or recommendations as authorized by statute.

Copy link

(16)

Take any action in a proceeding necessary to conduct and complete the case, consistent with applicable statutes, and precedents.

Copy link

(o)

During any proceeding, the secretary of state shall, upon motion or upon his own motion, direct all parties to attend an informal conference to aid in the disposition of the proceeding. Such conferences:

Copy link

(1)

May be recorded unless all parties wish to discuss possible settlements off the record. Such recordings shall be part of the record.

Copy link

(2)

Shall be held, in addition to settlement possibilities, to consider:

Copy link

(A)

Possible simplification of the issues.

Copy link

(B)

Possible amendments to the pleadings.

Copy link

(C)

Possible admissions of fact, admissions of documents, or other stipulations which might avoid unnecessary proof.

Copy link

(D)

The identification and possible limitations on the number of witnesses.

Copy link

(E)

Possible changes to the method of proceeding or hearing schedule which would otherwise be applicable.

Copy link

(F)

The distribution of written testimony, if any, and exhibits to the parties.

Copy link

(G)

Possible consolidation of the examination of witnesses by the parties.

Copy link

(H)

Any other matters which might contribute to the prompt, orderly, and fair conduct of the proceeding.

Copy link

(p)

A prehearing conference or other informal conference shall be conducted in person or, with the consent of the parties, shall be conducted by means of electronic communications.

Copy link

(q)

The presiding officer shall cause the administrative hearing to be electronically recorded. Such recording shall be made available, upon written request by a party and upon a fee sufficient to reimburse the full cost of providing the tape, or a true and accurate copy of such tape or tapes. A party may request, in writing, a transcript of the hearing but shall first pay the full costs for such transcription as determined by the secretary of state.

Copy link

(r)

In the event there is a clear dispute of facts between the parties in which credibility of testimony will determine the outcome of the hearing, the presiding officer on his own motion or that of a party, may sequester witnesses until they are called to testify.

Copy link

(s)

In any administrative hearing in which administrative action affecting the rights or privileges of any party may be taken, an oath or affirmation shall be administered by the presiding officer to each witness prior to receiving testimony, provided, however, that if a witness asserts an objection to the taking of an oath for religious or other related reasons, an affirmation shall be administered. Once a witness has been sworn at any hearing, it shall not be necessary to swear the witness again for subsequent testimony on the same day and in the same case. The record of the proceeding shall indicate that a person was recalled to testify and reminded that such person was still under oath or affirmation.

Copy link

(t)

Motions shall be in written form unless presented at the hearing. Written motions shall be included in the record of the proceeding and filed together with the case file. Oral motions shall be recorded in full in any transcript of the proceeding or, at the discretion of the presiding officer, noted in the minutes of the proceeding and submitted in written form within a reasonable time. A presiding officer may rule upon a motion when made or may defer decision until a later time in the hearing, or until after the conclusion of the hearing.

Copy link

(u)

Administrative hearings shall not be bound by common law or statutory rules of evidence, nor by technical or formal rules of procedure. All relevant, material, and reliable evidence shall be admissible. Such evidence may include, but shall not be limited to, depositions, affidavits, official documents, and testimony of witnesses. Provided, however, the presiding officer may, in the presiding officer's discretion, exclude any irrelevant, immaterial, unreliable, or unduly cumulative or repetitious evidence. Applicable statutory and constitutional provisions and immunities requiring exclusion of evidence in civil proceedings shall be recognized, provided, however, that nothing contained herein shall prohibit a party from waiving such party's privilege or immunity.

Copy link

(v)

Within a reasonable time after the hearing, the presiding officer shall issue a written decision stating the action to be taken by the department and may set forth findings of fact, conclusions of law, and disposition. All decisions shall be reached upon the basis of a preponderance of the evidence. The decision of the presiding officer shall be construed as the decision of the secretary of state.

Copy link

(w)

Any party to whom notice has been forwarded pursuant to and in accordance with this section who fails to appear shall have a default judgment rendered against him.

Copy link

(x)

The presiding officer may take judicial notice.

Copy link

(y)

Where the interests of justice will be better served without prejudice to the substantial rights of any party, a presiding officer may sever one case from another or may consolidate 2 or more cases, preserving to all parties the right of appeal from the single or several decisions rendered.

Copy link

(z)

Once a hearing notice has been issued commencing an adjudicatory proceeding, no party shall communicate with the presiding officer or the secretary of state concerning the merits of the case except upon notice to all parties nor shall any party cause another person to make such communications.

Copy link

(aa)

Within 30 days after a final decision, any party may file a motion for reconsideration which shall serve as a petition for rehearing under RSA 541. No distinctions shall be made between the terms "reconsideration" and "rehearing." A motion for reconsideration shall:

Copy link

(1)

Identify each error of law, error of reasoning, or erroneous conclusion contained in the final order which the moving party wishes the secretary of state to reconsider.

Copy link

(2)

Concisely state the correct factual finding, correct reasoning, and correct conclusion being advocated.

Copy link

(3)

Include any memorandum of law the petitioner wishes to submit.

Copy link

(bb)

Within 30 days after a final decision, the presiding officer may reconsider, revise or reverse any final action on the presiding officer's own motion. If reconsideration is based upon the existing record, prior notice shall not be given to the parties. If the presiding officer believes further information or argument should be considered, the parties shall be provided with an appropriate notice and opportunity to be heard before any revision is made in the previous action.

Copy link

(cc)

The filing of a motion for reconsideration shall not operate as a stay of any order or decision, but a motion for stay may be combined with a motion for reconsideration. Source. 2015, 273:1, eff. Jan. 1, 2016.

Copy link